Mastermind Groups
10:21 am in mentoring, power networking by Jane Chin, Ph.D.
You have probably heard sayings about how successful people have mentors and coaches and are members of mastermind (MM) groups.
But I wonder – just as coaches and mentors should come with a label that says “results may vary!” (or even “results not typical” like those infomercial program fine print at the bottom of the screen) – mastermind groups vary in quality and effectiveness as well.
Mastermind groups are often misunderstood and not created optimally – as I have learned from personal experience!
The people who are selected for masterminds must be at a comparable caliber of business achievement with slight deviations in business result. Members should have similar drive and goal standards. If these pieces are missing, the mastermind will not work to the members’ benefit. It’s a bit like playing tennis – you improve when you play with someone slightly better or much better than you – not someone who is a beginner, even if you are a beginner.
If you are a pro and you want to help others, then you can be a great mentor or coach. If you are a beginner, you want to learn from people who have done what you want to do, so you do not have to make the same mistakes!
In the past when I have been in similar groups I was often one who had already created a successful business, and other members were at the step of creating one or still figuring out what their business idea was. Even if I was looking to start a new business, I want to be amongst people who are starting their 2nd or 3rd of even 5th business – not 1st.
As a result, I found the meetings informative (I can always learn something from others) – but not truly educational for me to move forward in a meaningful way. When I have to pay money for it, then it becomes a waste of my hard earned dollars. Even if I didn’t have to pay for it, I do not want to waste precious time!
Another factor of a mastermind group is the facilitator’s skills. There are some who do not know how to run a mastermind group, and they appear to let the meeting wander in whatever direction the members move the meeting. Again, if this is the set-up of the mastermind (“we are here for creative brainstorming, so we are going to let ourselves wander and see where the conversation takes us”), then this is expected. On the other hand, I doubt that time-limited entrepreneurs like myself will have the patience to attend a meeting we thought had a clear agenda with defined goals, and we show up for a meeting where anything goes.
This is one of the reasons why I create mastermind groups with a specific “revenue achievement” pre-requisite. It is not so much about the dollar amount, as the amount of skill, drive, experience, and resourcefulness behind that revenue achievement. Someone who has a $500 a month business is at a different level than someone who has built a $5000 a month business, or someone who has taken a $5000 a month business to a $50,000 a month business.
If you have been a MM member – what makes the group work? What makes the group not work?
If you haven’t been a MM members – what would make you want to join one?
Image by Rodolfo Clix

I’ve found that the main requirement to asking more questions is to have an opening in my awareness that there is a lot that I don’t know, and that I will not fully grasp another person’s view unless I ask him or her. One of the benefits of assuming a position of “wonder” and asking more questions is that I can put my performance-ego on the backseat, relax, and enjoy learning about what the other person thinks.